29 leaders on Christmas

Each year the Herald offers an opportunity for the church leaders of Auckland to publish a meditation or reflection on Christmas.  This year’s appeared yesterday.  It was clearly penned from someone from a liturgical tradition, but is signed by 29 denominational leaders –  from the barely Christian (Seventh Day Adventist), the fairly liberal, through to the Destiny Church and various newer Pentecostal groups, and pretty much everyone in between.

Often I find these messages rather devoid of much distinctively Christian content.  In some ways, this one –  built around the modern Advent themes of hope, peace, joy and love – isn’t one of the worst I’ve seen.  Most of what it says, I can nod along to.  But there is that nagging feeling of “so what?” and “on what foundation does all this worthy stuff rest?”.

I presume the reason the church leaders generate these statements each year is, at least in part, evangelistic.  The incarnation certainly was intended that way –  good news. That God himself became fully human, as a baby born in an obscure provincial village, is astonishing enough.  That he came to suffer and die for our sin –  to reconcile us to God – is more staggering still.

Of course, there is something to be said for avoiding technical terms in pieces such as the Herald column.  But not even the concept of sin gets a mention –  the closest is a single mention of “evil”, but by implication that of others or institutions.  There is no sense of the barrier placed between man and God, by our own free choice and acts, which Christ comes to break down.  It isn’t even clear that the distinctly Christian perspective –  God who becomes man – is in the message.

When I worked in an office, I often wondered what  – if anything – about church could interest my colleagues in the gospel.  Perhaps I’m wrong, but in a sense the only inescapable proposition is the claim that our sin separates us from God, and that God acts to break down the wall that divides. Perhaps it is wrong, but we proclaim it as true –  the choice matters, for eternity.  Much else –  all the work in the community for example –  may be outworking of our faith; acts of love and discipleship in response to God’s initiative.  But on its own, it simply can’t seem that persuasive –  after all, lots of pagans do good deeds (fewer perhaps than Christians do, but…).

In our age, the concept of fault, of responsibility, of sin seems uncomfortable.  Perhaps they always were, but that was what serious religion was always about.   Our secular age seems particularly effective in airbrushing out the very concept, but not just from secular life; too often it is barely present even in our churches and their message.

What would have been lost from a forceful proclamation of the incarnation, of sin and the need for grace, in the Herald column?  I hope the answer is not just that they would then struggle to get 29 leaders to agree.

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “29 leaders on Christmas

  1. Jacqueline

    I don’t always hear the Queen’s Christmas message, but it seemed to me that she grew closer to acknowledging Jesus Christ as the Saviour as she aged. I found that heartening.

    Christmas is a pagan religion anyway, and consider the stress it causes. In the context of Xmas, Christians can only have the uppermost feeling they are obliged to keep up with the world. God is Love, so many Christians do OK with Christmas, if they choose.

    A better Way for Christians is to realise that the body of Christ leads humanity in all things Loving and True, whatever the day or season within His-story, throughout Life.

    I’m hard pressed not to feel sorry for those 29 church leaders. Perhaps if any dared to be different they would experience growing congregations. I suppose there are some rare church leaders who genuinely practise the spiritual talents of pastoring and teaching and apostleship. All the others seem to be in the wrong place as personalities and end up pandering to the world.

    It’s difficult not to get negative once we start analysing the word’s Christmas. I tell my children that at least New Zealand has public holidays which give a token gesture to what Christians believe and practise. In the grand scheme of things, this status quo is well worth our gratitude and respect – and with that comes the joy of Christmas!

    Living in a liberal land should also make it easier for Christians to buck the trend too. Therefore, the 29 could do better.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s